|
Costs of BRT in Selected Case Study
Cities
Costs for BRT systems vary widely depending on the BRT elements
being implemented (running ways, vehicles, etc.) and the location,
type and complexity of construction. A comparison of the costs shows
the following:
- Costs for bus tunnels range from about $200 to $300 million per
mile, including stations.
- Costs for busways on their own rights of way display a wide range,
depending upon the year built and ease of construction. The
values cited range from about $6 to $7 million in Los Angeles,
Miami, and Pittsburgh (South Busway), to about $20 million per
mile for the East Busway in Pittsburgh and the recently completed
South East Busway in Brisbane. The high cost of Pittsburgh’s
West Busway - about $53 million per mile – was due to the
hilly terrain traversed, a major tunnel rehabilitation, and an
expensive freeway interchange at the outer terminus of the busway.
- Costs for arterial street median busways have been reported as
about $1.5 million per mile in Curitiba, $5-8 million per mile
in Bogotá and Quito, and an estimated $29 million per mile
in Cleveland.
- Costs for mixed traffic operation have generally been less than
BRT systems with dedicated running ways. The costs reported for
guided bus systems include $2.4 million per mile of guideway in
Leeds, $7 million per mile in Rouen, and less than $5 million per
mile in Las Vegas. Table 9 below summarizes the full implementation
costs, including ITS and vehicles, for some recent BRT systems.
Table 9 – Full Implementation Cost per Mile
for recent BRT Services
City – System |
Capital Costs ($ million) /Mi.)* |
LA Metro Rapid Bus (Wilshire) |
$2 |
Las Vegas Max |
$3 |
Rouen TEOR |
$11 |
Boston Silver Line Phase I |
$20 |
LA Metro Rapid Bus (Ventura) |
$22 |
- Information on busway maintenance costs was only available for
Pittsburgh’s East Busway. These costs averaged $110,000 per
mile per year for seven miles.
- Operating costs for BRT service are influenced by wage rates
and work rules, fuel and electricity costs, operating speeds and
ridership. The comparisons in Table 10 suggest that BRT can cost
less per passenger trip and per mile than light rail transit, depending
on the situation.
Author: Ian McNamara
|